Order Food

We are now taking cake and cookie cake orders (for pick up at store location). Cake options and pricing below. (Other order options will be available later).

To order, review options below, then Click Here. After form is submitted, you will be sent an invoice from Square. Your cake is not ordered until payment is received. You must arrange pick up on the day you specify.

Please place and pay for your at least 2 full days before the day and you’ll pick it up for Friday through Monday pick up. Allow 3 days for Thursday pick up. No cake pick up on Tuesday or Wednesdays since we’re closed!

Prices are for basic decoration and writing. Other special requests cost extra. Upon placing your order, you’ll hear back with a cost for such requests. Please allow at least 2 days to allow time for clarifying such special requests, and 3 if picking up cake on a Thursday.

We also take orders for other items such as cupcakes, bars, brownies, etc. when purchasing 12 or more, and includes a 10% discount. You may either email us or use the order form and put the details of your order in the Notes section.

Please Note: Cakes shown are examples and may not be made exactly as shown, as baker has artistic license. Fresh fruit on cakes are an additional charge and must be ordered by special request.

Bananarama Bakery Cake Flavor and Price List

Cake SizeServesStandardPremiumGluten free
6” 3 layer3-6$40$46Add $8
9” 2 layer6-12$50$57.50Add $10
9” 3 layer12-16$65$74.75Add $13
12” 2 layer16-30$95$109.25Add $19
12” 3 layer30-50$130$149.50Add $26
14” 2 layer40-60$125$143.75Add $25

We also now sell Cookie Cakes, which are a large cookies with your choice of frosting. Available in Chocolate Chip, Lemon Poppyseed, and Snickerdoodle.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
Cookie Cake9″12”14”
Any kind-regular$32$40$50
Gluten Free$38$48$60

Cupcakes: 1 dozen minimum. Sold by the dozen. $3-$3.75 each depending on flavor, filling, decoration. Most cake flavors available as cupcakes. Gluten-Free are an additional 20% over standard cupcake price.

Tiered cakes and larger cakes— message for a quote

Cake Flavors

Standard Flavors

Almond/ Lemon Cream-almond cake with lemon cream frosting

Banana Caramel-banana cake with caramel frosting

Banana Chocolate Chip-banana cake with chocolate chips and chocolate frosting

Chocolate-chocolate cake with chocolate frosting (or any other frosting)

Chocolate Orange-orange cake, chocolate frosting

Chocolate Peanut Butte -chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting

Coconut-coconut cake with coconut frosting, covered in coconut

Coconut Lilikoi-coconut cake, lilikoi frosting 

Kona Mocha Fudge-chocolate cake, mocha frosting

Lemon-lemon cake with vanilla frosting

Lemon Ginger-lemon ginger cake with candied ginger bits and lemon or vanilla frosting

Lemon Poppyseed-lemon poppyseed cake with vanilla frosting

Pandan-green pandan cake, coconut blossom frosting

Red Velvet-red velvet cake with tangy vanilla frosting

Yellow cake with any frosting

Premium Flavors

Banana Cream Pie-banana cake, banana cream filling, vanilla frosting, graham cracker crumble

Banana Split-banana cake, strawberry & pineapple filling, chocolate ganache, vanilla frosting, maraschino cherry

Carrot Cake-carrot cake with pineapple and coconut and tangy vanilla frosting

Chocolate Banana Custard-banana cake, banana custard filling, chocolate frosting

Chocolate Lilikoi-chocolate cake, lilikoi curd filling, chocolate frosting

Chocolate Raspberry-chocolate cake, raspberry frosting

Coconut Lilikoi Dragonfruit-coconut cake with dragonfruit, lilikoi frosting 

German Chocolate– chocolate cake, toasted coconut and pecan filling, chocolate frosting

Hawaiian Hummingbird Cake-Banana, pineapple, coconut and macadamia nut cake with lilikoi (passionfruit) frosting (Additional 10% charge over other Premium cakes)

Lemon Blueberry-lemon blueberry cake, blueberry filling, vanilla frosting

Mango Lime-mango lime cake with chunks of mango in it with mango frosting

Orange Cranberry– orange cranberry cake with orange frosting

Piña Colada-pineapple rum cake, coconut frosting

Samoa Cake-(like the Girl Scout cookie) chocolate cake, caramel frosting, covered in toasted coconut, caramel and chocolate drizzle

Strawberry-yellow cake, strawberry filling, vanilla frosting

Triple Chocolate– chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream, and chocolate ganache

Tropical Dream-pineapple brown sugar cake, lilikoi frosting

Volcano Cake-chocolate cake, chocolate frosting, lilikoi lava glaze (has a bit of heat from chipotle in the glaze)

Cake Flavor Pictures

Standard Flavors

Almond/ Lemon Cream-almond cake with lemon cream frosting

Lemon Almond Cake

Banana Caramel-banana cake with caramel frosting. One of our 3 signature cakes!

Banana Caramel Cake

Banana Chocolate Chip-banana cake with chocolate chips and chocolate frosting

Banana Chocolate and Pandan Cakes

Chocolate-chocolate cake with chocolate frosting (or any other frosting)

Chocolate Cake

Chocolate Orange-orange cake, chocolate frosting

Chocolate Orange Cake

Chocolate Peanut Butter-chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake

Coconut-coconut cake with coconut frosting, covered in coconut

Coconut Cake

Coconut Lilikoi-coconut cake, lilikoi frosting. One of our 3 signature cakes! 

Ube Coconut, Coconut Lilikoi, & Pandan Cakes

Kona Mocha Fudge-chocolate cake, mocha frosting. One of our 3 signature cakes!

Kona Mocha Fudge Cake

Lemon-lemon cake with vanilla frosting (sorry no pic of this cake)

Lemon Ginger-lemon ginger cake with candied ginger bits and lemon or vanilla frosting (sorry no pic of this cake)

Lemon Poppyseed-lemon poppyseed cake with vanilla frosting

Lemon Poppyseed Cake

Pandan-green pandan cake, coconut blossom frosting

Pandan Cake with Coconut Sugar Frosting

Yellow cake with any frosting

Red Velvet-red velvet cake with tangy vanilla frosting (sorry no pic of this cake)

Premium Flavors

Banana Cream Pie-banana cake, banana cream filling, vanilla frosting, graham cracker crumble

Banana Cream Pie Cake

Banana Split-banana cake, strawberry & pineapple filling, chocolate ganache, vanilla frosting, maraschino cherry

Banana Split Cake

Carrot Cake-carrot cake with pineapple and coconut and tangy vanilla frosting

Carrot Cake

Chocolate Banana Custard-banana cake, banana custard filling, chocolate frosting

Chocolate Banana Custard Cake

Chocolate Lilikoi -chocolate cake, lilikoi curd filling, chocolate frosting

Chocolate Lilikoi Cake

Chocolate Raspberry-chocolate cake, raspberry frosting

Chocolate Raspberry Cake

Coconut Lilikoi Dragonfruit-coconut cake with dragonfruit, lilikoi frosting 

Coconut Lilikoi Dragonfruit Cake

German Chocolate-chocolate cake, toasted coconut and pecan filling, chocolate frosting

German Chocolate Cake

Hawaiian Hummingbird Cake-banana, pineapple, coconut and macadamia nut cake with lilikoi (passionfruit) frosting

Custom Hawaiian Hummingbird Cake

Lemon Blueberry-lemon blueberry cake, blueberry filling, vanilla frosting

Lemon Blueberry Cake

Mango Lime-mango lime cake with chunks of mango in it with mango frosting

Mango Lime Cake

Orange Cranberry-orange cranberry cake with orange frosting

Orange Cranberry Cake

Piña Colada-pineapple rum cake, coconut frosting (sorry no pic of this cake)

Samoa Cake-(like the Girl Scout cookie) chocolate cake, caramel frosting, covered in toasted coconut, caramel and chocolate drizzle

Samoa Cake

Strawberry Shortcake-yellow cake, strawberry filling, vanilla frosting

Strawberry

Triple Chocolate-chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream, and chocolate ganache (sorry no pic of this cake)

Tropical Dream-pineapple brown sugar cake, lilikoi frosting

Tropical Dream Cake

Volcano Cake-chocolate cake, chocolate frosting, lilikoi lava glaze (has a bit of heat from chipotle in the glaze) (sorry no pic of this cake)

Place Order